The Paradox of Personalization – 5 Ways to Get it Right
Why consumers welcome tailored experiences — until brands cross the line between relevance and surveillance.
Guest article by Alfredo Deambrosi, head of content, Imgix
Consumers want relevance but reject intrusive targeting. This article explains five principles for privacy-led personalisation that keeps trust intact.
According to consumer research, 84% of consumers say it’s “cool” to receive a personalized birthday offer, and 80% appreciate recommendations based on their past purchases. But when the personalization crosses into unexpected territory, like being targeted based on a hyper-specific physical location or your search on Keto recipes leads to ads for weight loss drugs, the cool factor quickly becomes uncomfortable.
This shifting perception raises an important challenge for marketers: how to navigate the line between personalization that delights and personalization that disturbs. This tension between relevance and surveillance is especially pronounced when it comes to visual experiences, when smart image optimization can help build a brand’s reputation.
From Helpful to Offputting
For years, consumers didn’t know how brands acquired their data, and the lack of transparency made every well-timed ad feel like it came with a hidden camera.
People are more tolerant of personalized content when it feels appropriate and beneficial, like receiving holiday discounts. On the other hand, when a friend texts you about their recent vacation to Cabo and later that evening, you begin seeing pop ups for flights and hotel discounts in Mexico it starts to burn trust.
Privacy-Led Marketing (PLM) is the opposite of that. It’s asking people what they want to share, respecting their choices and giving them something they consider valuable in return. It’s the foundation for building trust and boosting marketing performance.
The key lies in consent and transparency. People aren’t inherently against personalization. They just want to know what data you’re using, why you’re using it, and how it improves their experience.
The Personalization Paradox
The paradox is this: four-fifths of customers globally report they are comfortable with personalized experiences, however, two-thirds of customers say that they have recently had at least one personalized experience with a brand that was inaccurate or invasive. In many instances, these experiences caused the customers to unsubscribe, disengage, or simply not come back.That’s a tightrope walk for any marketing team.
The closer you get to individual targeting, the higher the risk of turning people off - especially if you can’t explain where the data came from. So, the question is, how do you keep your visual personalization sharp without triggering the user?
Visual content plays a massive role in perception. A smart visual strategy can feel intuitive and even meaningful. A clumsy one? Instant distrust. Here are five principles to get it right:
1. Design for context, not intrusion
Use non-invasive data like device type, time of day, or general location to tailor your visuals. This form of “ambient personalization” avoids the need for deep personal data while still delivering relevant imagery.
2. Respect the line between audience and individual
Don’t chase hyper-specificity if you can’t do it transparently. Focus instead on segment-based optimization i.e. serve images designed for runners, not just one runner.
3. Build in consent and transparency
Be upfront about what you personalize and why. If visuals shift based on behavior, say so. Transparency builds trust, and trust is the only real foundation for long-term engagement.
4. Let the user lead
Offer options for image preferences, like themes or display styles. Allow them to opt in to personalization features. Visual customization can feel empowering if it doesn’t feel forced.
5. Optimize to impress
The best visual experiences spark joy. Birthday offers are a hit because they feel thoughtful, not targeted. When optimizing images, ask yourself: “will this visual surprise and delight, or will it make someone squint at their webcam in suspicion?”
Keep the Trust and Create Relevance
You don’t need to compromise user trust to create relevance. Smart image optimization lets you adapt visuals in real time based on contextual signals, not data trails.
It enables:
Instant format and resolution adjustments for different devices and screen sizes
A/B testing and performance feedback for visual assets
Dynamic visuals that respond to time of day or campaign without tracking individuals
This technology puts the control back in marketers’ hands, allowing them to design visuals that are engaging and performant without crossing the line.
Final thoughts: Boundaries
Personalization is not an issue for consumers, but manipulation is. Effective, personalized visuals build a positive and memorable brand experience, while intrusive ones feel like a violation of privacy. For brands to be seen as credible, they need to prioritize building consumer trust by respecting boundaries, not just following legal guidelines.
Alfredo Deambrosi, head of content, Imgix
Alfredo Deambrosi leads content at Imgix, where he turns complex visual tech into compelling narratives. With a background in education and B2B marketing, he brings clarity and relatability to every story. Previously at Perspectium, Safesite, and Ondaro, he now helps shape the voice behind Imgix’s mission to power high-performance visual experiences.
Thanks for reading all the way to the end of the article! This post is public so feel free to share it, and if you have not done so already sign up and become a member.